My husbands two favorite things are Better Than Sex Cake and Apple Pie. This year when I asked him which one he wanted for his birthday, he stated, “Better than Sex Apple Pie.” What the heck does that mean? I mean chocolate apple cake with toffee and caramel sounded like a bit of overkill. So this is what I came up with.
Better than Sex Apple Pie
1 double pie crust (mine was homemade)
2/3 recipe for a yellow cake (homemade in my case or you can use a box)
2 cups apple pie filling (also homemade is best, drained and juices set aside)
1 heath candy bar
1 can sweetened condensed milk
Preheat oven to 350 F. Set aside a pie tin with half the pie crust lining the bottom. Mix the boxed cake mix or your own cake according to recipe directions. Pour into pie tin and bake for 25 minutes.
Heat sweetened condensed milk and the apple pie filling juices. Thicken, this may take a long time.
Make your own apple pie filling or open a can. Drain all juices (KEEP!). After cake has partially baked place the pie filling on top. Use 1/2 of the sweetened condense mixture and spoon over apple pie filling. Top with crust. Bake additional 15-20 minutes.
Cool. Crush Heath bar and sprinkle over top. Serve with vanilla ice cream, some of the sweetened condensed milk sauce, and enjoy!